The Wiert Corner – irregular stream of stuff

Jeroen W. Pluimers on .NET, C#, Delphi, databases, and personal interests

  • My badges

  • Twitter Updates

  • My Flickr Stream

  • Pages

  • All categories

  • Email Subscription

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 717 other subscribers

CRS305-1G-4S+ cannot talk to SFP on RBS960 at DuckDuckGo

Posted by jpluimers on 2026/11/18

With RouterOS on both sides, the symptoms where that both the CRS305-1G-4S+ and the RBS960 (hEX PoE) would see the 6COMGIGA 10GBase-SR SFP+ Transceivers, but not establish a link.

Two RBS960 would establish a link fine and I had enough RBS960 lying around to use those.

If I recall correctly, this used to work fine in RouterOS before my year cancer treatments started in at the end of 2019. Now that we’ve moved and I got more equipment in our larger house, things do not work as expected.

Reminder to self that when I start working on this again, it might be a negotiation setting of the SFP module in the SFP+ port and I need to script the work-around:

Queries:

Relevant results:

  • [Wayback/Archive] SwOS Update Broke SFP+ Compatibility on CRS305-1G-4S+ – #9 by rajkosto – SwOS – MikroTik community forum

    Have you tried forcing the link speed to 1G on them, then rebooting the SwOS, then setting it back to autonegotiate ? that makes my no-name 1G RJ45 SFP modules work on this cursed switch.

  • [Wayback/Archive] CSS326-24G Firmware 2.13 update broke SFP Module – SwOS – MikroTik community forum

    …

    They won’t work on CRS305 in RouterOS AT ALL, but this trick makes them work on SwOS 2.13:
    Force 1G full duplex on SwOS for the affected modules and hit apply
    Reboot SwOS
    Set the mode back to auto-negotiation and hit apply
    Voila, they now work perfectly ! Until you reboot or unplug the affected modules, that is, then you have to repeat the steps.
    Make sure NOT to set 10G Sfp modules as force 1G in this step, cuz then they WONT work when you set them back to auto-negotiate after.
    This is some firmware bug about SFP/SFP+ init vs force link speed, and Mikrotik has not fixed it for years.

    …

    My CSS106 RB260G firmware v2.13 has exactly the same problem, the Mikrotik SFP module does not work. I have requested a copy of v2.12 to see if it makes a difference.

    …

    on CRS305
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/223426779978 does not work unless on SwOS and using trick where its forced to 1G, rebooted, then set to auto
    cisco GLC-T works under RouterOS and SwOS when 1G forced, when forced Link ON stays on all the time even if unplugged (never Rx Loss)
    different 1000 only SFP module under RouterOS and SwOS when 1G forced, Rx Loss/Link On/Off properly reported when forced
    none of these work in 10/100 autoneg or forced mode under either OS, you need Mikrotik 10/100/1000 SFP for that.

  • [Wayback/Archive] CRS305-1G-4S+IN 5 Port Desktop Switch config issues – Beginner Basics – MikroTik community forum

    By default, CRS devices are configured to act as switches between all ports. So the problem you’re experiencing is most probably not configuration error.
    I don’t have a CRS305, but I believe that the RJ45 port is intended for management. Thus it might not be part of switch ports group.

    Mikrotiks are quite notorious for sub-optimal support for SFP modules. And if they are supported, speed autonegotiation might not work. So verify these things:

    1. is SFP module detected and recognized?
    2. did port speed negotiate to 1Gbps (you’re writing about 1Gbps all over so I’m assuming the optical link peer supports 1Gbps and not 10Gbps).
      If it didn’t, try to disable autonegotiation and set speed to 1Gbps

    If you’re using SFP+ RJ45 module to connect the copper device, repeat the steps written above also for the RJ45 port.

    …

    As you run the SFP+ port at 1G (and so probably are using an SFP): did you disable autonegotiation and set the port to 1G FDX? If you don’t, the link will seem to come up, but no traffic will flow. Been there, done that…

  • [Wayback/Archive] MikroTik CRS305-1G-4S+IN out of box troubles – #9 by JimF – Hardware – MikroTik community forum

    Bingo, that turned out to be the cat’s meow. It was not negotiating with the SFP modules, as soon as I TOLD them how to connect, it connected.

Other results:

  • a
  • a
  • a
  • a
  • [Wayback/Archive] RB5009 not working with sfp? – RouterOS beta – MikroTik community forum

    Good morning everyone,

    A number of users owning an RB5009 are unable to connect to delta fiber networks using their existing sfp adapter (adapter and config are running fine with a HexS) so we are wondering whether the RB5009 would only work with sfp+ adapter? Is there anyone who can shed a light on this?

    …

    I think you can rightfully conclude that this is unacceptable. Maybe we should return the RB5009’s we bought so far.

  • [Wayback/Archive] Mikrotik switch SFP+ port issue on COLD restart – MikroTik hardware general – MikroTik community forum

    …

    I have a crs226-24g-s2+rm running v6.42.11 (long-term), which has an odd issue with SFP+ port not coming back up after AC/DC loss.

    …

    To get the SFP+ to come back up, I need to

    • goto interfaces, uncheck “Enabled”, press Apply, wait 5 seconds
    • check off Enabled, and press Apply again

    All resumes working, and life is good again until power is lost.

    Is there anyway to script something to do this automatically upon boot everytime (shutdown sfpplus1, wait , restart it) ?

    …

    SFP is a HUAWEI MA5671A which works perfect otherwise…

    …

    Trying to add a work around while getting this worked out…

    added a start up script that seems to kinda work (3/5 tries) – I wonder if interface set sfp-sfpplus1 disabled= yes/no is equivalent to the GUI’s “Enabled” checkbox. No idea how to get to a shell prompt yet.

    interface set sfp-sfpplus1 disabled=yes
    delay 5
    interface set sfp-sfpplus1 disabled=no

    …

    I have written a script to reset sfp if issue happens, you can use it accordingly.

    :local HOST "192.168.1.1"
    :local PINGCOUNT "10"
    :local INTF "sfp-sfpplus1"
    :local DELAY "3s"
    :log info "Delay 10s."
    :delay 10s
    :log info "Start pinging $INTF."
    :if ([/ping $HOST interval=1 count=$PINGCOUNT] = 0) do={
    :log error "Interface $INTF is down, restarting..."
    /interface ethernet set $INTF auto-negotiation=no
    :delay $DELAY
    /interface ethernet set $INTF auto-negotiation=yes
    :log warning "$INTF restart complete."
    } else={
    :log info "$INTF is working."
    }

    …

    I have a related issue with 328-24P-4S.

    The site suffers from frequent power-cuts and when power comes back some of the switches wont talk on SPF. Its wierd though. Lets say you have 3 switches daisy chained – after power comes back SW3 devices appear offline, yet SW3 shows up in neighbors list on SW1.

    After a lot of checking and testing whats happening is traffic from SW3 is making it back to SW2 and SW1, but traffic to SW3 and its devices isnt making it past SW2 and the SFP on SW2 TX shows counters at zero.

    Rebooting hard and soft doesn’t clear the issue. You have to power SW2 down for about 10min then it works again.

    This issue has been present through many firmwares and still present in 7.17.

    …

    …

    …

    …

Some less related but still interesting results:

  • a
  • a
  • a
  • a
  • [Wayback/Archive] Strange issue when using SFP+ port compared to ether1 – Beginner Basics – MikroTik community forum

    …

    Bingo! Doohhh! That was the problem. I got totally sidetracked by the fact my DHCP was working and could ICMP ping, but they must have some deeper filtering.
    I realised this when I browed to http IP address and I got a redirect to an internal ISP page, so routing was obviously working. I cloned the mac and tada!!

--jeroen

Leave a Comment