
Discourage apps from showing my account to logged-out users Bluesky will not show your profile and posts to logged-out users. Other apps may not honor this request. This does not make your account private. Note: Bluesky is an open and public network. This setting only limits the visibility of your content on the Bluesky app and website, and other apps may not respect this setting. Your content may still be shown to logged-out users by other apps and websites.
This is the reason you cannot limit your skeets from harvesting by machine learning sites: [Wayback/Archive] Bluesky Firehose Explained: Real-Time Data Streaming with Jetstream & ATProtocol | Skyscraper
Basically the “posts only visible only to people who are signed in.” is a suggestion to the BlueSky UI front-end, not to the protocols in the back-end that handle your data. Those protocols is what’s described in the above Firehose link.
It means that the new Attie AI scraper always has access to everything you published as it has access to the above Firehose and the BSKY APIs. Anything/anyone with access to that Firehose or the BKSY APIs can access all your data.
The whole “Logged-out Visibility” is just a suggestion, the actual underlying protocols and their access are very much not explained in this visibility post:
[Wayback/Archive] Post by @safety.bsky.app — Bluesky
Logged-out Visibility
Bluesky is a public network, but sometimes, added friction matters. If you don’t want Bluesky to show your content to logged-out users, opt out in the Moderation screen.
On the right I emphasised the privacy consequence in italic.
The Firehose and it’s risks aren’t at all covered in posts like [Wayback/Archive] Why I’m betting on ATProto (and why you should, too).
This is to different from the Fediverse of which Mastodon is the most well known social network, as described by [Wayback/Archive] Mastodon Migration: “How About Some AI With Your BlueSky…” – Mastodon
Read the rest of this entry »